<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=374562230457954&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">
Skip to content

What GCSE Results Cannot Tell You About a School

Every independent school in the country publishes its results. They appear in league tables, in prospectuses, in the footnotes of ISI reports, and in the inevitable conversation at an open morning when a parent, having admired the facilities and liked the look of the teachers, asks the question they have been working up to: how do your pupils do?

It is a fair question, and the answer here is a good one. Leweston's GCSE and A level outcomes are strong, consistently so, and we would not want anyone to think otherwise but results are, at best, a partial answer to what a parent is really trying to find out when they ask that question, and we think the honest thing to do is to say so.

What the numbers measure

A league table position tells you how a school's pupils performed, in aggregate, against a set of criteria assessed at a specific moment in time. It does not tell you whether those pupils were challenged appropriately for their individual ability. It does not tell you whether they developed genuine intellectual curiosity, or only the skill of performing well under examination conditions. It does not tell you what happened to the child who found Year 10 very difficult, and what the school did, and whether it worked.

None of this is an argument against caring about results. It is an argument for understanding what results can and cannot tell you about a school.

The difference between performing well and being prepared

There is a distinction worth making between a pupil who achieves strong grades because they have been well prepared for the examination, and a pupil who achieves strong grades because they have genuinely understood and engaged with the subject. The former can produce excellent results in the short term, the latter produces a person who is equipped to keep learning after the examination is over.

At Leweston, the approach is to prioritise the second thing, and to trust that the first follows from it. By the time a Leweston pupil sits an examination, they know how to think under pressure, how to organise an argument, and how to produce their best work rather than simply their safest. The grade is the outcome of something. The thinking is the preparation for everything that comes after.

The things a school visit will show you that a table cannot

What a league table cannot show you is the conversation between a teacher and a pupil who is struggling. It cannot show you the moment a child who thought they were not a science person discovers, in a lesson that is genuinely engaging, that they are. It cannot show you how the school responds when a family is going through something difficult, or how teachers talk about pupils in a staff meeting, or what a child does with the space between lessons.

When families come to Leweston, those are often the things they notice first. The quality of a conversation with a teacher. The way a pupil answers a question, not with a prepared line but with something that sounds like genuine thought. The sense that the school knows these children individually and cares about them specifically, not as entries in a cohort.

Those things do not show up in a results table. They show up in what a young person is like at eighteen, and in what they go on to do, and in the confidence with which they meet the parts of adult life that no examination prepared them for. Results matter, so does the person who produces them, and the school that formed them. We think it is worth asking about both.

If the question of what lies beyond results interests you, this piece sets out our thinking on what future readiness actually means, and why we believe it is the right measure of what a school is doing: What are we actually preparing children for?

Ready to find out more?

Call 01963 211015 or visit leweston.co.uk to book a visit or speak to the team. 

Leweston School is a co-educational independent day and boarding school in Sherborne, Dorset, for pupils aged 3 months to 18.

Related Posts